Equity Compensation
Decoding Equity Compensation: A Comprehensive Guide for Job Candidates
For many job seekers, particularly in tech and startup environments, equity compensation represents a significant but often confusing component of the total compensation package. While the potential upside of equity can be substantial, understanding the various forms it takes, its actual value, and the restrictions that may apply is crucial before accepting any offer.
This guide breaks down the complex world of equity compensation to help you make informed decisions about your career and financial future.
Understanding the Basics
At its core, equity compensation gives you partial ownership in the company where you work. This ownership can take various forms, each with different characteristics, risks, and potential rewards. Before diving into specifics, it's important to understand a few fundamental concepts:
Equity: Ownership interest in a company, usually represented as shares or stock options
Valuation: The estimated worth of the company, which affects the value of your equity
Dilution: The reduction in ownership percentage that occurs when new shares are issued
Liquidity: The ability to convert your equity into cash
Remember that equity is fundamentally different from salary. While salary provides guaranteed income, equity represents potential future value that depends on the company's performance and future events.
Types of Equity Compensation
Common Stock
What it is: Common stock represents basic ownership shares in a company, the same class typically held by founders and early employees.
Key characteristics:
Most basic form of ownership
Usually has voting rights
Stands last in line during liquidation events
Value fluctuates directly with company valuation
When you might receive it: Early-stage startups sometimes offer common stock grants to founding team members or first employees, though this has become less common.
Potential advantages:
Direct ownership from day one
Potential for long-term capital gains treatment if held for sufficient time
No need to make a cash payment to acquire the shares
Potential disadvantages:
Immediate tax implications (taxation on fair market value when granted)
May be subject to company repurchase rights if you leave
Lower priority than preferred shares in liquidation scenarios
Restricted Stock Units (RSUs)
What it is: RSUs are promises to grant you a specific number of shares of company stock upon meeting certain conditions, typically time-based vesting requirements.
Key characteristics:
Shares are delivered to you only after vesting
No purchase required – you receive the full value of the stock
Taxed as ordinary income when vesting occurs
More commonly offered by later-stage private companies and public companies
When you might receive them: Mid to late-stage startups, pre-IPO companies, and public companies commonly offer RSUs.
Potential advantages:
No upfront investment required
Always retain some value as long as the stock has value
Simpler to understand than options
Potential disadvantages:
Taxed upon vesting even if you can't sell the shares (in private companies)
No control over timing of taxation
Often subject to double-trigger vesting in private companies (time and liquidity event)
Stock Options
What it is: Stock options give you the right, but not the obligation, to purchase company stock at a predetermined price (the "strike price") for a specific period.
Key types:
Incentive Stock Options (ISOs):
Only available to employees
May receive preferential tax treatment
Subject to specific holding requirements for optimal tax treatment
Strike price must be at least fair market value at time of grant
Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs/NQSOs):
Can be granted to anyone (employees, contractors, advisors, etc.)
No special tax treatment
Subject to ordinary income tax on the spread between strike price and fair market value at exercise
Key characteristics:
Require you to "exercise" (pay to buy the shares) to realize value
Only valuable if the company's stock price exceeds your strike price
Have an expiration date (typically 10 years from grant)
Usually require you to exercise within a limited window after leaving the company
When you might receive them: Common at early to mid-stage startups, less common at public companies.
Potential advantages:
No immediate tax impact when granted
Potential for significant upside if company value increases substantially
With ISOs, potential for favorable long-term capital gains treatment
Potential disadvantages:
Require cash outlay to exercise
Risk losing exercise price if company fails
May trigger Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) when exercising ISOs
Create complex tax planning requirements
Employee Stock Purchase Plans (ESPPs)
What it is: Programs that allow employees to purchase company stock, usually at a discount of up to 15% from the market price.
Key characteristics:
Typically only available at public companies
Purchases made through payroll deductions
Often include "lookback provisions" that allow purchasing at the lower of the price at beginning or end of offering period
Subject to specific IRS rules and limitations
When you might receive it: Primarily offered by public companies.
Potential advantages:
Guaranteed discount to market price
No risk until you choose to participate
Potential tax advantages if qualifying disposition requirements are met
Potential disadvantages:
Limited to specific contribution amounts
May increase concentration of wealth in employer's stock
Complex tax rules for optimal treatment
Preferred Stock
What it is: A class of stock with specific rights and preferences beyond those of common stock.
Key characteristics:
Priority in receiving proceeds during liquidation events
May include specific dividend rights
Often has conversion rights to common stock
Usually includes protective provisions
When you might receive it: Rarely offered to employees; typically reserved for investors.
Potential advantages:
Better downside protection than common stock
May include guaranteed returns through liquidation preferences
Often includes information rights and other investor protections
Potential disadvantages:
Rarely available to employees
Complex legal structures
May conflict with employee interests in certain exit scenarios
Phantom Stock
What it is: A promise to pay a bonus equal to the value of a specified number of shares, without actually granting equity ownership.
Key characteristics:
Cash bonus based on stock value
No actual equity ownership
Payment triggered by defined events (time period, company sale, etc.)
Taxed as ordinary income when paid
When you might receive it: Companies that want to provide equity-like incentives without diluting ownership or sharing equity.
Potential advantages:
No purchase requirement
Simple from employee perspective
Can be structured flexibly
Potential disadvantages:
No actual ownership stake
No potential for capital gains treatment
Usually completely illiquid until payment event
Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)
What it is: Rights to receive the increase in the value of a designated number of shares over a specified period.
Key characteristics:
Compensation equal to stock price appreciation
No actual share ownership
Can be settled in cash or stock
No purchase required
When you might receive it: Companies looking to provide equity incentives without diluting ownership.
Potential advantages:
No upfront cost or investment
Upside potential similar to stock options
Simpler than actual equity ownership
Potential disadvantages:
No actual ownership stake
Taxed as ordinary income
Usually completely illiquid until specific events occur
Important Terms and Concepts
Vesting Schedules
What it is: The timeline over which you earn the right to your equity.
Typical structures:
Time-based: Equity vests over a specific period (most common)
Milestone-based: Equity vests upon achieving specific company or individual milestones
Hybrid: Combination of time and milestone requirements
Standard practices:
4-year vesting period for initial grants (most common)
Monthly or quarterly vesting increments after the cliff
Additional grants ("refreshers") may begin vesting immediately
Accelerated vesting possible in some acquisition scenarios
Questions to ask:
"What is the vesting schedule for this equity grant?"
"Does the vesting schedule reset if I receive promotion grants?"
"Is there any acceleration of vesting in case of company acquisition?"
Cliffs
What it is: An initial period during which no equity vests, after which a larger first portion becomes available.
Typical structures:
One-year cliff (most common): No equity vests until 12 months of service, then 25% vests immediately
No cliff: Equity begins vesting immediately (typically monthly or quarterly)
Extended cliffs: Longer than 12 months (less common and often a red flag)
Questions to ask:
"Is there a cliff, and if so, how long is it?"
"What happens to my equity if I leave before the cliff date?"
"Does the cliff apply to all equity grants or just the initial one?"
Exercise Windows
What it is: The period during which you can purchase your vested options after leaving the company.
Typical structures:
Traditional: 90 days after termination (most common)
Extended: 5-10 years after termination (increasingly common at employee-friendly companies)
Early exercise: Ability to exercise options before they vest (with restriction)
Implications:
Short windows may force cash-constrained employees to forfeit options
Tax implications vary based on when you exercise
Extended windows reduce pressure but may impact ISO tax treatment
Questions to ask:
"How long do I have to exercise my options if I leave the company?"
"Are there any circumstances where the exercise window is extended?"
"Do you offer early exercise options with the ability to file an 83(b) election?"
Strike Price
What it is: The price at which you can purchase shares when exercising stock options.
How it's determined:
Must be at least the fair market value at time of grant
Set by the board based on 409A valuation
Generally increases with subsequent funding rounds
Implications:
Lower strike price = more potential value
The gap between strike price and fair market value at exercise is taxable
Significant factor in determining the potential value of your options
Questions to ask:
"What is the strike price for these options?"
"When was the last 409A valuation, and what was the per-share value?"
"How often does the company perform new 409A valuations?"
Fair Market Value (FMV)
What it is: The assessed value of a single share of company stock.
How it's determined:
Early-stage: Based on 409A valuation (typically lower than investor price)
Public companies: Current trading price
Acquisition scenarios: Based on transaction value
Implications:
Directly affects stock option value
Determines tax obligations upon exercise
May differ significantly from what investors pay (preferred stock)
Questions to ask:
"What is the current fair market value per share?"
"How has the FMV changed over the past few years?"
"What is the most recent investor price per share, and how does it compare to the FMV?"
409A Valuations
What it is: An independent assessment of a private company's common stock fair market value.
Key points:
Required by IRS regulation for setting option strike prices
Typically performed every 12 months or after significant events
Always lower than preferred stock price (due to liquidation preferences)
Creates "safe harbor" for companies to avoid tax penalties
Implications:
Directly affects the value of your equity grants
Lower valuations generally benefit employees receiving options
Higher valuations generally benefit employees with existing equity
Questions to ask:
"When was the last 409A valuation completed?"
"How has the 409A valuation changed over time relative to the preferred price?"
"What factors might significantly impact the next 409A valuation?"
Ownership Dynamics
Preferred vs. Common Stock
Key differences:
Typical owners
Employees, founders
Investors
Liquidation priority
Last
First
Economic rights
Basic ownership
Special rights (preferences)
Conversion rights
None
Usually convertible to common
Price
Lower (409A valuation)
Higher (negotiated)
Voting power
Full voting rights
Varies by agreement
Implications for employees:
Your common shares/options have less protection than investor shares
Company value would need to exceed the liquidation preferences for common to have value
The gap between common and preferred value (preference overhang) creates risk
Questions to ask:
"What is the current preference overhang for common stock?"
"What preferences do the preferred stockholders have?"
"Under what exit scenarios would common stock have significant value?"
Liquidation Preferences
What it is: The right of preferred shareholders to receive their investment back before common shareholders receive anything.
Typical structures:
1x non-participating: Preferred shareholders get their money back, then all share proceeds proportionally
Multiple preference (2x, 3x): Preferred shareholders get multiple of their investment back first
Participating preferred: Preferred shareholders get investment back AND share in remaining proceeds
Implications for employees:
Higher liquidation preferences require higher exit values before common stock has value
Later-stage companies with multiple rounds may have complex preference stacks
Liquidation preferences may reduce or eliminate value for common stockholders in modest exits
Questions to ask:
"What are the current liquidation preferences for each investor class?"
"Are the preferences participating or non-participating?"
"At what exit valuation would common stock begin receiving proceeds?"
Anti-Dilution Provisions
What it is: Protections for existing shareholders against dilution from future financing rounds at lower valuations.
Common types:
Full ratchet: Adjusts conversion price to match any lower future round
Weighted average: Adjusts conversion price based on size of down round relative to company value
Pay-to-play: Requires investors to participate in future rounds to maintain anti-dilution protection
Implications for employees:
Anti-dilution provisions protect investors at the expense of common shareholders
Can significantly reduce common stockholder ownership percentage in down rounds
Most impactful during difficult fundraising environments
Questions to ask:
"What anti-dilution protections do current investors have?"
"How would these protections impact common shareholders in a down round?"
"Have anti-dilution provisions been triggered in the past?"
Voting Rights
What it is: The ability to vote on major company decisions.
Typical structures:
Common stock: Usually one vote per share
Preferred stock: May have special voting rights on specific matters
Voting agreements: Founders and key shareholders may have agreements to vote together
Implications for employees:
As a common shareholder, your voting power is usually minimal
In smaller companies, employee equity collectively may have meaningful influence
Some equity grants may explicitly limit voting rights
Questions to ask:
"What voting rights come with this equity?"
"Are there any protective provisions requiring investor approval for major decisions?"
"What percentage of voting power do employees collectively hold?"
Liquidity Events
Initial Public Offerings (IPOs)
What it is: The process of offering shares of a private company to the public through a new stock issuance.
Key considerations for employees:
Lockup periods: Typically 180 days after IPO when employees cannot sell shares
Trading windows: Even after lockup expires, you may be restricted to specific trading windows
Vesting acceleration: IPOs rarely trigger acceleration of unvested equity
Registration rights: Whether your shares are registered for immediate sale
Timeline and process:
Company files S-1 registration statement with SEC
Roadshow to market shares to institutional investors
Pricing and initial trading
Lockup period (typically 180 days)
Employee trading windows based on company policy
Questions to ask:
"Is the company considering an IPO in the foreseeable future?"
"What would be the lockup policy for employees?"
"Would an IPO affect the vesting schedule of my equity?"
Acquisitions
What it is: The purchase of a company by another entity.
Implications for employee equity:
Treatment of unvested equity: May be assumed by acquirer, accelerated, or canceled
Conversion of equity: How your equity converts into acquirer's equity or cash
Earn-outs: Portions of purchase price tied to future performance
Retention packages: Additional incentives to stay with acquirer
Common scenarios:
Cash acquisition: Equity converted to cash based on purchase price allocation
Stock acquisition: Equity converted to acquirer stock based on exchange ratio
Hybrid: Combination of cash and stock consideration
Questions to ask:
"How has the company approached acquisition offers in the past?"
"Does my equity agreement include acceleration provisions in case of acquisition?"
"What happens to underwater options in an acquisition?"
Secondary Markets
What it is: Private transactions where current shareholders sell shares to outside investors.
Key characteristics:
Not available at all companies (requires company approval)
Often limited to specific investors approved by the company
May involve discounts to reflect illiquidity
Typically subject to right of first refusal by the company or existing investors
Implications for employees:
Potential for partial liquidity before company-wide exit
May require board approval and have quantity limitations
May be available only to certain employees (executives, early employees)
Questions to ask:
"Does the company allow secondary transactions for employee equity?"
"Are there specific windows or programs for employee secondary sales?"
"What approvals are required for secondary transactions?"
Tender Offers
What it is: Organized opportunities for existing shareholders to sell some portion of their shares, typically to investors or the company itself.
Key characteristics:
Company-facilitated process (not individual transactions)
Usually open to all or specific classes of shareholders
Often occurring alongside new funding rounds
Typically at a specified price (often the same as a recent investment round)
Implications for employees:
Opportunity for partial liquidity
Usually limited to selling a percentage of your vested shares (e.g., 10-20%)
More structured and transparent than secondary markets
Questions to ask:
"Has the company conducted tender offers in the past?"
"What percentage of vested shares were employees permitted to sell?"
"How does the company determine the price for tender offers?"
Direct Listings
What it is: An alternative to traditional IPOs where a company lists existing shares on an exchange without issuing new shares.
Key characteristics:
No lockup periods typically required
No new shares issued (only existing shares become tradable)
Less control over initial trading price compared to IPO
Lower banking fees than traditional IPOs
Implications for employees:
Potentially faster liquidity than with traditional IPOs
More market-driven price discovery
May create more immediate selling pressure without lockups
Questions to ask:
"Is the company considering a direct listing instead of a traditional IPO?"
"What would be the policy on employee sales in a direct listing scenario?"
"Would all employees have equal access to selling in a direct listing?"
Holding Periods and Tax Implications
Tax Treatment by Equity Type
RSUs:
Taxed as ordinary income at vesting based on FMV
Additional capital gains/losses upon sale based on change from vesting value
Withholding typically automatic for public companies
Stock Options (NSOs):
No tax at grant
Taxed as ordinary income on the spread between strike price and FMV at exercise
Additional capital gains/losses on sale based on change from exercise value
No automatic withholding typically (must plan for tax payment)
Stock Options (ISOs):
No tax at grant
No regular income tax at exercise (but may trigger AMT)
Qualifying dispositions (hold 2+ years from grant and 1+ year from exercise) eligible for long-term capital gains on entire gain
Disqualifying dispositions treated partially as ordinary income
Employee Stock Purchase Plans (ESPPs):
No tax at enrollment
Qualifying dispositions (hold 2+ years from offering date and 1+ year from purchase) may have portion of discount treated as ordinary income
Disqualifying dispositions have full discount treated as ordinary income
Important considerations:
Tax laws vary by country and state
Rules can change, requiring ongoing tax planning
Professional tax advice recommended for significant equity holdings
Short-term vs. Long-term Capital Gains
Short-term capital gains (assets held ≤1 year):
Taxed at ordinary income rates (up to 37% federal as of 2023)
Subject to state income taxes where applicable
Apply to stock sold within 1 year of acquisition
Long-term capital gains (assets held >1 year):
Lower tax rates (0%, 15%, or 20% federal depending on income as of 2023)
3.8% Net Investment Income Tax may apply for higher incomes
State taxes still apply where applicable
Strategic planning considerations:
Holding periods begin when you acquire actual shares (not when options granted)
For RSUs, period begins at vesting
For options, period begins at exercise
Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)
What it is: A parallel tax system designed to ensure high-income individuals pay minimum tax.
ISOs and AMT:
Exercising ISOs creates an AMT preference item equal to the spread between strike price and FMV
This can trigger significant AMT liability even without selling shares
Creating potential cash flow problems for large ISO exercises
Can generate AMT credits for future years
Planning considerations:
Exercise planning across calendar years to minimize impact
Early exercise (when available) to reduce or eliminate AMT
Modeling various exercise scenarios with professional guidance
83(b) Elections
What it is: An election to be taxed on equity at grant rather than at vesting.
When it applies:
Early exercise of stock options (exercising unvested options)
Restricted stock with vesting requirements
Must be filed within 30 days of receiving the stock (strict deadline)
Benefits:
Starts capital gains holding period immediately
Limits ordinary income taxation to current (typically lower) value
Potentially significant tax savings for appreciating companies
Risks:
Pay tax on shares you may forfeit if you leave before vesting
No refund if stock value declines or company fails
Irrevocable once filed
Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS)
What it is: Special tax treatment for stock in qualifying small businesses.
Key benefits:
Potential for 100% exclusion of capital gains (up to greater of $10M or 10x investment)
Must be C-Corporation with gross assets under $50M when stock issued
Must hold for 5+ years
Must be original issue stock (not purchased from another shareholder)
Implications for employees:
Could significantly reduce or eliminate taxes on equity gains
Particularly valuable for early employees in successful startups
Requires documentation and holding period planning
Evaluating Equity Offers
Company Stage Considerations
Early Stage (Seed/Series A):
Higher risk but potentially higher reward
Significant dilution expected in future rounds
Equity typically makes up larger percentage of compensation
Valuation multiples from current to exit might be 10-100x+
Growth Stage (Series B/C/D):
More established business model with clearer path to success
Moderate dilution still expected
Valuation multiples from current to exit might be 3-10x
More data available to assess potential outcomes
Late Stage (Series E+/Pre-IPO):
Lower risk but also lower potential multiple
Minimal dilution expected before exit
Valuation multiples from current to exit might be 1-3x
Clearer timeframe to potential liquidity
Dilution Expectations
Typical dilution scenarios:
Each major funding round: 15-30% dilution
Employee option pool refreshes: 5-15% dilution
Potential total dilution before exit:
Early stage to exit: 50-80%
Mid-stage to exit: 30-50%
Late stage to exit: 10-30%
Implications for offer evaluation:
Factor expected dilution into value calculations
Consider option pool size and future hiring plans
Understand current capitalization table if possible
Exit Timelines
Realistic timeline expectations:
Early stage to exit: 7-10+ years
Growth stage to exit: 3-7 years
Late stage to exit: 1-3 years
Implications for offer evaluation:
Align expected timeline with personal financial goals
Consider opportunity cost of illiquid compensation
Assess company's realistic exit opportunities
Comparative Analysis
Between different offers:
Calculate equivalent cash value using reasonable assumptions
Consider exercise costs and tax implications
Factor in different risk profiles and timelines
Apply personal risk tolerance and discount rates
Between public and private options:
Adjust private equity for illiquidity discount (25-50%)
Consider certification value of different employers
Evaluate genuine belief in company vision and upside
Negotiation Strategies
Information Gathering
Critical information to request:
Total company shares outstanding (fully diluted)
Most recent preferred price per share
409A valuation per share
Historical valuation growth
Detailed vesting schedule
Expected timing of next financing or liquidity event
Questions about future plans:
Fundraising strategy and timeline
Expected dilution from future rounds
Exit strategy and timeline
Competitive landscape considerations
Tradeoff Considerations
Potential negotiation levers:
More equity for less cash compensation
Shorter vesting schedules vs. larger grants
Earlier exercise windows
Larger initial grants vs. refresh expectations
Guaranteed refreshes vs. performance-based grants
Strategic approaches:
Focus on ownership percentage, not just share count
Consider total compensation package holistically
Prioritize terms that align with your risk profile and timeline
Key Questions to Ask
About current equity structure:
"What percentage of the company would these shares represent?"
"What liquidation preferences exist for preferred shareholders?"
"How many rounds of financing do you anticipate before an exit?"
About historical patterns:
"How has the per-share price changed over the last several rounds?"
"What dilution have employees experienced in previous rounds?"
"How has the company handled underwater options in the past?"
About future expectations:
"What is the anticipated timeline to liquidity?"
"What equity refresh practices does the company follow?"
"How does the company approach equity compensation as it matures?"
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Overvaluing potential upside:
Assuming best-case scenarios without probability weighting
Ignoring liquidation preferences in exit calculations
Failing to account for dilution in future rounds
Underestimating costs:
Exercise costs for options (potentially significant)
Tax implications (especially AMT for ISOs)
Opportunity cost of illiquid compensation
Documentation gaps:
Not getting equity grants in writing
Failing to understand all terms and conditions
Missing filing deadlines for tax elections
Timeline misalignment:
Joining a company with a expected exit timeline that doesn't match your financial needs
Not considering your likely tenure against vesting schedule
Ignoring the extended timeframes common in private companies
Resources for Further Learning
Online calculators and tools:
Option Impact (compensation data)
eShares Exercise Calculator
Carta Equity Education Center
Books:
"Consider Your Options" by Kaye Thomas
"Equity Compensation for Tech Employees" by Josh Maher
"An Introduction to Stock & Options" by David Weekly
Professional guidance:
Tax professionals with equity compensation expertise
Financial advisors familiar with startup equity
Equity compensation specialists
Remember that equity compensation is complex, and even experienced professionals sometimes struggle with its intricacies. When in doubt, seeking professional advice specific to your situation is usually worth the investment, particularly as the potential value of your equity increases.
Note: This guide provides general information only and is not legal, tax, or financial advice. Tax rates, rules, and equity structures change over time. Always consult qualified professionals for advice specific to your situation.
Last updated